Depression….Is It All in Your Mind?

May 22, 2013

Depression….Is It All in Your Mind
Sherry Allchin

More From

Sherry Allchin

Depression….Is It All in Your Mind

BCC Staff Note: You’re reading Part Three of a four-part BCC Grace & Truth blog mini-series on depression. In addition to today’s post by Sherry Allchin, you can read Part One by Lilly Park: Depression and Imbalanced Approaches and Part Two by Pat Quinn: Depression, Catastrophizing, and Elijah. And in Part Four, Pastor Paul Tautges will examine Disciplines of a Depressed Soul.

A Compassionate Approach

Is depression purely a physiological condition of hormones or chemicals out of balance, or is there a heart/mind connection, or do both play a role? The experts have disagreed, so how do we as biblical counselors help those who suffer from depression? How can we help without pushing them further down into the quagmire of despair and shame?

First, we must acknowledge that depression is real. Just read Psalms 32, 38, 102 to see that God gives voice to our deepest pain and hears our cries. The symptoms of depression affect both body and soul, and are enough to make a person deaf and mute, withdrawn and unproductive. Life turns inward and nothing but one’s pain matters at that moment. The depressed need empathy, not sympathy. Encouragement, not excuses. Help, not judgment.

A Comprehensive Approach

We are fearfully and wonderfully made, and God created us with both a body and a living soul. One without the other is an incomplete human experience. Heart, soul, spirit, mind, and conscience are all aspects of the inner person, the place where desires and emotions emanate. The body gives expression to those desires. To understand depression requires looking at both the body and the inner person and connecting the dots.

If the person has not recently had a thorough physical, that should be step one—to be sure a medical doctor has determined there is no disease (such as Parkinson’s or diabetes) causing the body to respond in depression.  I remember one woman we counseled that presented increasingly depressed and after several sessions, no obvious reason for her depression surfaced. We sent her to another doctor for a second opinion, and Dr. # 2 found a small tumor on her thyroid that he removed. In just a few weeks she bounced back into the office to report how good she felt again, depression all gone! Her issue was not spiritual and all the Bible studies in the world would not make her feel upbeat until the physical problem was corrected.

Exploring Spiritually-Rooted Dimensions of Depression

However, our experience is that much depression has a root in the spiritual dimension of a person’s life. Disappointment sets the stage for depression. No, it’s not sin to feel disappointed about something. But disappointment can lead to a sinful attitude when that desire is not processed through a heart that loves and desires to please God more than any temporal thing or achievement. When heart desires lead us back to God’s sovereignty over our life and submission to His plans for us, the disappointment and related trials lead us to growth and maturity (James 1:2-4).

If the person has responded to disappointment and difficult circumstances with anger toward God and others, then the downward spiral into depression begins. Discontentment with situations and often with God becomes evident as bitterness and complaining grow. Unless repentance and change occur at this stage, the downward spiral continues into despair where the person loses all hope and believes life will never be good again. The ultimate sinful solution is destruction through suicide or homicide, depending on whether the person focuses internally or externally.

Let me also say here that suicide is not always physical. One person may commit social suicide by leaving everyone and moving on to avoid the disappointing people, while another commits mental suicide with drugs and alcohol, zoning out of the disappointing circumstance. Spiritual suicide denies God, trying to erase Him from a disappointing life, and emotional suicide retreats inward to hopeless despair through a psychological diagnosis that debilitates life and normal function. At least these can all be reversed, whereas a successful physical suicide is permanent.

The downward spiral from disappointment to discontentment to despair to destruction can move very quickly in some, and more slowly in others, but this is a common pattern we observe with those who are depressed. When I show the chart, The Development of Spiritually-Rooted Depression, to my counselees, they typically recognize very quickly where they are at that moment and how they progressed to that point. We then begin to identify the belief system that allowed them to process the disappointments as they did, and to replace those wrong beliefs with a Biblical worldview that honors Christ.

I will often ask a depressed counselee to journal daily how they are feeling, and then to trace that back to what they were thinking about their life circumstances and how their behaviors corresponded to what they were thinking and feeling about the situations they faced. My goal is to help a depressed person who has evaluated their circumstances as too hard, or hopeless, or some other negative, to begin to see that negative evaluations produce negative behaviors, producing negative emotions!

Think about the Psalms…they are a kind of emotional journal, with the psalmist pouring out a heart of disappointment, fear, anger, depression, shame, loneliness or betrayal and expressing the pain that comes with wrong thinking or wrong actions or being sinned against. The focus is inward, on self as it relates to circumstances, and often exposes a wrong view of self, others, or God. But the Psalms have what I like to call a “But GOD!” verse that lifts our chins upward to see the true and living God Who is much bigger than our problems and circumstances. That can change everything in our thinking and actions!

Therefore, my goal in asking someone to journal (or even talk during a counseling session) is to help them see their own belief system about their problems and circumstances, and then help them compare that to what Scripture teaches about our God. As they begin to see God as He IS and to adjust their beliefs to embrace Truth, their actions begin to adjust, and in time their emotions can adjust, too. The depression that they once experienced because of believing their circumstances were hopeless and their God was impotent is replaced with trust in God and joy in the Lord, even if the disappointing circumstances continue and even if some trying emotions remain. Why? Because their new (biblical) interpretation of the circumstances sees God as bigger than any circumstance He could ever face!

Join the Conversation

As a biblical counselor, how do you address depression compassionately and comprehensively while exploring spiritually-rooted dimensions?

As you personally struggle with depression, how could exploring the development of spiritually-rooted depression help?


2 thoughts on “Depression….Is It All in Your Mind?

  1. Pingback: Sherry Allchin. Depression….Is it all in your mind? | Weblioteca

  2. Thank you Sherry. This is as succinctly put as I’ve ever seen it. It’s difficult to compress an integrous response to depression that takes in to account both physical and spiritual dynamics in one small article. But you have done that beautifully.

Comments are closed.