Why Do We Fight?, Part 1: The Source of Our Conflicts

July 18, 2011

Paul Tautges

More From

Paul Tautges

Why Do We Fight Part One

As Karen Carpenter pondered the painful moments of being in and out of love, her mellow voice painfully cried out, “Can’t we stop hurting each other?”

Deep within the human heart are self-loving desires that are so strong and so determined to be satisfied that, when thwarted, lead to conflicts with those who get in the way of their fulfillment. How can we counsel each other to identify and repent of these hidden desires and to esteem others as better than ourselves?

Why We Don’t Get Along

Instead of building each other up, our flesh often produces words and actions that lead to “making each other cry, breaking each other’s heart, tearing each other apart.” Why is that? James 4:1-3 gives us the reason: What is the source of quarrels and conflicts among you? Is not the source your pleasures that wage war in your members? You lust and do not have; so you commit murder. And you are envious and cannot obtain; so you fight and quarrel. You do not have because you do not ask. You ask and do not receive, because you ask with wrong motives, so that you may spend it on your pleasures.

James answers his own question about the source of habitual quarrels. They are caused by inward pleasures. The Greek word is the same as that from which we get our word “hedonism,” which “denotes the enjoyment derived from the fulfillment of one’s desires, or, as here, the craving for the pleasure itself…the yearnings of self-love” (Hiebert). Earlier in his letter, James reveals the origin of sinful temptations as the enticement of our own lust (1:14).

Scripture never allows us to shift the blame for our sin to anyone else. Our sin is always our responsibility. Regrettably, unlike Moses, we often choose “the passing pleasures of sin” (Hebrews 11:25) because self-exalting pleasure is exactly what our heart craves.

These self-centered desires “wage war” in our bodily “members” (cf. James 3:6). They cause great conflict inside of us that then spills into our relationships with others. Harry Ironside defined these strong desires as, “unrestrained and unlawful desires struggling for fulfillment in our very being.” Hiebert identifies these passions as “conflicting cravings, which throw the individual into inner turmoil, they are the expressions of the believer’s old nature seeking self-satisfaction.”

Why We Do What We Do

In other words, deep within the human heart are self-loving desires that are so strong and so determined to be satisfied that, when thwarted, lead to conflicts with those who get in the way of their fulfillment. “You lust and do not have; so you commit murder. And you are envious and cannot obtain; so you fight and quarrel” (James 4:2).

Jerry Bridges writes, “Resentment, bitterness, and self-pity build up inside our hearts and eat away at our spiritual lives like a slowly spreading cancer. All of these sinful inner emotions have in common a focus on self. They put our disappointments, our wounded pride, or our shattered dreams on the thrones of our hearts, where they become idols to us” (The Practice of Godliness).

Unlike Karen Carpenter, who did realize how much we hurt each other, but “without ever knowing why,” the Scriptures expose the why of what we do. Our resident lusts continually beg to be stroked and worshiped. And when others refuse to bow down and serve them and keep us exalted to the lofty place where we think we belong, our flesh is willing to wage war to get the respect we think we deserve. This is nothing short of idolatry.

Until we learn to ask the why questions, such as, “Why am I willing to murder my brother in the heart?” which is what anger is, we will never get to the root of our sins. Until we begin to see the hidden motives of our hearts, we will fail to see how Christ came to set us free from the “sins of the heart” just as much as our outward, habitual sins. And we will be less helpful than we could be in counseling one another. Thankfully, we have the Word of God, which is able to judge the thoughts and intentions of our deceptive hearts (Hebrews 4:12).

The Rest of the Story

But how do we identify these sinful, selfish desires? And what do we do once we become aware of them? Return for Part Two: Repenting of Idolatrous Desires.

Join the Conversation

What other questions can we ask ourselves to better uncover the hidden desires of our hearts?


6 thoughts on “Why Do We Fight?, Part 1: The Source of Our Conflicts

  1. An interesting read and very true indeed. The roots of most conflicts and problems are selfishness and pride. Interesting how these create problems in a relationship

  2. Pingback: Worth a Look 7.19.11 : Kingdom People

  3. Pingback: this and that: 07.19.2011 | a certain man

  4. Pingback: Why Do We Fight?, Part 1: The Source of Our Conflicts | shelboese.org

  5. Pingback: Why Do We Fight? | One Pilgrim's Progress

  6. Pingback: The Top 25 Most Popular BCC Blog Posts of 2011 | Biblical Counseling Coalition Blogs

Comments are closed.